American Idol Predications for March 23-24: Will Thia Megia Go Home?


Here are Your Punish Predictions for American Idol


  • Stephan Langone
  • Thia Megia
  • Naima Adedapo


Theia is the best singer of these bottom 3, probably in the top 5 of all who’s left.
However, she’s too vanilla, has no style, not ready to display any artistic interpretations of herself because she has no life scars yet.

She’s not ready……but I predict she will be hot in about 2 to 4 years from now.
She blew some lyrics and that’s a huge NO NO!
That could be the difference here.

I would sign her to a development deal and let her heart get broken a few times before she really sings in public.
She needs that pain to sing…..then, she will be a huge talent.

Naima Adedapo
She will go home in the next 2 weeks.
She’s too strange for the American general public
Her singing is mediocre but her performance art is compelling
Put her on Broadway in an African-style show.
If she does NOT make it tonight, it was the African thing that turned middle America off.

Stephan Langone
Great kid….rock star?  No
He will be going home soon.
Needs to go wild and take some chances to save himself from going home in the next 3 weeks.


  • Jacob Lusk:  Big voice, can gospel last?  Big voices make it to Top 5
  • Scotty McCreery:  Middle America loves his stuff.  Will swing into top 5
  • Casey Abrams:  Joe Cocker crazy man antics will keep him in the top 10, probably top 5
  • Lauren Alaina:   They love her channeling of Carrie Underwood style.  Can she step out and rock it?  She would need to turn up the heat to get into Top 5
  • Paul McDonald:  Strange tweaky moves have their place in commercial art.  But he will hit a roadblock when his limited range slams the wall.  His schtick could get old if he can’t diverse.
  • Haley Rhinehart:  A bit quirky, yet compelling.  Just not enough power to put it over the top.   Could be a Top 5er if she turns on those quirky jets and lights up the stage.


  • Pia Toscano:  Celine Dion is a huge success.  Pia has that in her.  A lady who can sing it all.  If she can step out a bit and challenge James to a duel. She can cash in and take it all.
  • James Durbin:  The straight Adam Lambert!  Adam did NOT win it cause middle America is bigoted.  This could be the time when Adam gets the real vote in as he’s channeled through the body of James Durbin.  This rocker has attitude, pipes, and disposition.


  1. Pia Toscano
  2. James Durbin
  3. Jacob Lusk
  4. Scotty McCreery
  5. Casey Abrams
  6. Lauren Alaina
  7. Paul MacDonald
  8. Haley Rhinehart
  9. Stephan Langone
  10. Naima Adedapo
  11. Thia Megia